Knowledge hub · Insight

Do you need a new website for AI?

Usually not. Most websites need an upgrade for AI visitors rather than a rebuild, and here is what that upgrade covers and when starting again is the honest answer.

A small brick cottage under repair, with scaffolding, a crane hoisting a window frame, a glowing lantern, stacked bricks and tool trays, in an isometric illustration.

Usually not. Google says its AI answers in Search draw on pages already in its index, and that appearing in them needs nothing extra, so most websites need a careful upgrade rather than a rebuild. That holds whether yours runs on WordPress, was hand-coded or is a set of static pages.

Why do so many owners think they need to start again?

Because “AI” sounds like a new world, and a new world sounds like it needs a new website. It is an understandable worry, and a costly one if it leads to throwing away a site that works.

We have already looked at whether your website is ready for AI visitors. This piece is the next question: if it is not quite ready, what does fixing it involve?

What does Google actually say?

Google’s guide to optimising for AI search says Google’s AI features are built on its core Search ranking and quality systems. They fetch relevant pages from the existing index, check what those pages say, and show links to them in the answer.

Its page on AI features and your website adds that the usual good search practice still applies, and that appearing in AI Overviews and AI Mode needs no special optimisation. Google even says that optimising for AI search is, from its side, still just optimising for search, whatever name it is sold under.

The thing Google expects to matter most in the long run is content people find unique, compelling and useful. Its own example: a first-hand review gives a view nobody else has, while a summary of other pages only repeats what is already out there.

One honest caveat. That guidance is about Google Search. Other AI assistants are not covered by it, so we treat it as a strong guide rather than a rule for every tool.

What does the upgrade look like?

None of this needs a new platform. It is careful work on the site you have.

  • Words in the page itself. Your main words should be part of the page, not only added by a script after it loads. Words that are simply there are the easiest for any reader to pick up.
  • Clear headings. One main heading per page, then headings that say what each section answers.
  • Structured data about your business. A short, machine-readable note in the page saying who you are, where you are and what you offer.
  • Prices, areas and hours as plain text. Not only inside an image, a PDF or a pop-up. If a customer would ask, the answer should be written on the page.
  • Forms that work without tricks. Every field labelled, a clear button, and a clear message when it has sent.
  • Speed. A page that arrives quickly is better for everyone who visits, whoever or whatever they are.

On WordPress this is mostly theme, plugin and content work. On a hand-coded or static site it is edits to the pages and templates. Different tools, the same list.

When is a rebuild the honest answer?

Sometimes it is, and we would rather say so than patch something that will not hold. A rebuild is usually the better choice when:

  • You cannot change your own words without paying someone every time, and the platform will not let that change.
  • The platform or theme is no longer looked after, so each fix sits on something that is quietly ageing.
  • Almost every item on the list above means fighting the site rather than editing it.
  • The business has changed so much that the site describes someone you no longer are.

If fixing the old site would cost more than building a sound new one, that is the answer, and you should hear it plainly.

Where should you start?

Pick your three most important pages and check them against the list above. Most sites pass some items and miss others, and the misses are usually fixable in place.

If you would like a second pair of eyes, Marbl Codes reviews and upgrades existing websites for AI visitors, whatever they are built on.

New pieces, straight to your inbox

What is changing in web design, development and AI, written for people who run a business. One email a week. Unsubscribe with one click.

We will email you once to confirm. See our privacy policy.

Want this done for you?

No obligation, no jargon, no pressure

Tell us what you’re trying to do. We’ll tell you where to start.

Start a project

We plant trees for every client we work with. Our forest grows on Ecologi.

Our ethos

We’re active in our local community, from the Chamber to the football club.

Our community

Free guide

What is a good website, really?

Last thing